Gisha Legal Center for Freedom of Movement.

  •  
  •  
  •  
  • About
    • About Gisha
    • Board
    • Gisha Staff
    • FAQs
    • Vacancies
    • Institutional Donors
  • Topics
    • Control over Gaza
    • Economy and Development
    • Access to Education
    • Family Unity
    • Residency Rights
    • Other
  • Legal Activity
    • Legal Advocacy
    • Procedures and Protocols
  • Media
    • Gisha in the media
    • News Releases
    • Media Inquiries
  • Reports & Data
    • Publications
    • Graphs
    • Gaza up close
  • Gallery
    • Image Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Get information
    • UNDO the closure
    • Campaigns
  • Updates
    • Updates
    • Gisha in Action
  • Contact Us
Legal Activity » Legal Advocacy » Following petition by Gisha, Gaza resident able to travel to the Dutch Embassy in Tel Aviv and reunite with her spouse in the Netherlands

Following petition by Gisha, Gaza resident able to travel to the Dutch Embassy in Tel Aviv and reunite with her spouse in the Netherlands

January 31, 2019. Gisha filed a petition on behalf of a Gaza resident married to a Dutch citizen. The petitioner hoped to travel to the Netherlands to reunite with her spouse and begin their new life together. In order to do so, she was required to first attend an interview at the Dutch Embassy in Tel Aviv and take a written test. About a week before the interview she had scheduled at the embassy, Israel denied her permit application on the grounds of unspecified security reasons, also called a “security block.”

In the petition (Hebrew), we argued that the security-based denial of our petitioner’s permit was arbitrary and had no factual basis, as is the case in hundreds of other instances. We further argued that the decision to deny her permit was disproportionate given the profound infringement on her rights, as it effectively forced her to live apart from her spouse for an unspecified amount of time though she has done nothing wrong.

When the petition was submitted, the state withdrew the “security block” and informed the court that the petitioner would be allowed to exit Gaza and travel to the interview but only on a direct shuttle organized by the Palestinian Civil Affairs Committee. Gisha objected to this stipulation, at which point the petitioner was summoned for a security interview. The state then withdrew its demand and agreed to let the petitioner travel independently to the interview at the embassy.

Once the petition was deleted, Gisha filed a motion to issue a costs order against the state. Judge Sarah Dovrat dismissed (Hebrew) the motion despite ruling that the petitioner had undisputedly obtained the remedy thanks to our petition.

The reasoning provided for the motion’s dismissal is particularly troubling as it is based on a factual and legal error: Judge Dovrat found that “the security grounds at the foundation of the refusal had not been disproven.” This finding contradicts the state’s update whereby the “security block” had been lifted after the petitioner provided satisfactory clarifications to Israeli authorities regarding the suspicions raised. The judge also found that: “due to the large number of permit applications, it is impossible to perform security screening for each and every person applying to enter Israel.”  We believe this finding is incongruent with the legal obligation of the authorities to make decisions based on facts, rather than assumptions. Not only is this finding erroneous, it also legitimizes the practice of the Israel Security Agency applying “security blocks” arbitrarily.

     

More in Legal Advocacy

  • Following Gisha’s High Court petition, Israel allows travel from Israel into Gaza for mourning rituals during the pandemic
  • Following petition, Israel allows a Palestinian woman to move back to the West Bank with her young children
  • Following petition, Israel allows a 75-year-old widow to return home to the West Bank from the Gaza Strip
  • Following petition, Israel allows a mother and her four children to return home to the West Bank from the Gaza Strip
  • Court ordered deletion of petition filed on behalf of a cancer patient wishing to return to her home in Gaza from Jordan, after her condition deteriorates

Gisha's Blog

Recent posts:
Cosmetic dreams‬
04.03.2021
A love too far away‬
14.02.2021
Back to the West Bank‬
31.01.2021
Donate
Get information
1.4 Million Did you know that seventy percent of the population in Gaza, 1.4 million people, are under 30 years old?
Watch the video
Gallery
Distant | Relatives
facebook icon   Gisha on Facebook
twitter icon   Gisha on Twitter
  • Homepage
  • About
  • About Gisha
  • Board
  • Gisha Staff
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use
  • Vacancies
  • Legal Activity
  • Legal Advocacy
  • Procedures and Protocols
  • Media
  • Gisha in the media
  • News Releases
  • Reports & Data
  • Publications
  • Graphs
  • Gaza Up Close
  • Gallery
  • Image Gallery
  • Video Gallery
  • Updates
  • Updates
  • Gisha in Action
  • Get Involved
  • Donate
  • Get information
  • Contact Us
 TechnoCraft |  בניית אתרים | סטודיו ג2 | Copyright © 2021 Gisha.org