Gisha Legal Center for Freedom of Movement.

  •  
  •  
  •  
  • About
    • About Gisha
    • Board
    • Gisha Staff
    • FAQs
    • Vacancies
    • Institutional Donors
  • Topics
    • Control over Gaza
    • Economy and Development
    • Access to Education
    • Family Unity
    • Residency Rights
    • Other
  • Legal Activity
    • Legal Advocacy
    • Procedures and Protocols
  • Media
    • Gisha in the media
    • News Releases
    • Media Inquiries
  • Reports & Data
    • Publications
    • Graphs
    • Gaza up close
  • Gallery
    • Image Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Get information
    • UNDO the closure
    • Campaigns
  • Updates
    • Updates
    • Gisha in Action
  • Contact Us
Legal Activity » Legal Advocacy » Petition on behalf of Ms. Safadi and her children who are requesting to return to their home in the Gaza Strip, HCJ 6999/11

Petition on behalf of Ms. Safadi and her children who are requesting to return to their home in the Gaza Strip, HCJ 6999/11

A petition filed on September 27, 2011 in the case of a resident of Gaza, Mrs. Safadi, who traveled to the West Bank to visit family she hadn't seen in some eight years, only to have military authorities refuse her return to her home in Gaza, claiming a lack of humanitarian grounds for doing so.

Mrs. Safadi lives in the Gaza Strip, though her registered address is in the West Bank. She and her husband have five young children. In April 2010, after not having seen her family in the West Bank for many years, she submitted an application to visit them, which was approved. In July 2010, when the visit was over, Mrs. Safadi submitted an application to return home with her children. When she did not receive a response, Gisha contacted the military authorities on her behalf, requesting that their return be arranged. The request was refused in a response dated June 2, 2011, which stated that passage could not be approved as there were no exceptional humanitarian grounds for doing so. Following the refusal, Gisha notified the State Attorney’s Office of its intent to file a petition to the High Court of Justice (HCJ). On September 27, 2011, Gisha filed the petition.

In the petition Gisha argued that Mrs. Safadi’s passage through the Erez Crossing was marked by serious errors on the part of the army. So, for example, as a condition for crossing, she was told to sign a document written in Hebrew (a language Mrs. Safadi does not understand) entitled “Statement of Undertaking”. The document states that under the current policy pertaining to passage, only passage on humanitarian grounds is permitted and family relations do not constitute such humanitarian grounds. However, army officials told Mrs. Safadi that what the document meant was that when she wanted to return to the Gaza Strip, she would have to file another application at her local District Coordination Office in the West Bank.

Contrary to Mrs. Safadi’s claim, the military authorities contended that she was presented with an Arabic version of the “Statement of Undertaking”. Yet, even if an Arabic version was indeed presented, the authorities nevertheless failed to satisfy their obligations considering the significant differences between the two versions. The Arabic version contains no mention of the policy on passage. Moreover, even if Mrs. Safadi had signed the “Statement of Undertaking” lawfully, these could not prevent her from returning to her home. Gisha further argued that the refusal to allow Mrs. Safadi and her children to return contravened common practice and that it violated a number of the family’s rights, including the right to return to one’s home and the right to family life. Gisha argued that the decision was neither proportionate nor reasonable and that it contravened Israel’s obligations toward Palestinian residents.

On November 7, 2011, before a hearing in the petition took place, the authorities retracted their refusal to allow Mrs. Safadi and her children to return home, and the family returned to the Gaza Strip on November 16, 2011. However, as a condition for re-entering Gaza, Mrs. Safadi was required to sign a document in which she declared that the center of her life was in the Gaza Strip and that she was aware of the military commander’s policy on the issue. On December 15, 2011, the court accepted Gisha’s motion for trial costs and ordered the state to pay 4,000 shekels to the organization.

The petition, dated September 27, 2011 (Hebrew)
The Hebrew Statement of Undertaking, dated April 2, 2010 (Hebrew)
The Arabic Statement of Undertaking, dated April 25, 2010 (translated into Hebrew)
The state’s response to the petition, dated November 9, 2011, approving Mrs. Safadi’s return on condition that she signs a document declaring the center of her life is in the Gaza Strip (Hebrew)

     

More in Legal Advocacy

  • Following petition, Israel allows a Palestinian woman to move back to the West Bank with her young children
  • Following petition, Israel allows a 75-year-old widow to return home to the West Bank from the Gaza Strip
  • Following petition, Israel allows a mother and her four children to return home to the West Bank from the Gaza Strip
  • Court ordered deletion of petition filed on behalf of a cancer patient wishing to return to her home in Gaza from Jordan, after her condition deteriorates
  • Israel denies two sisters’ participation in mourning rituals for their father in the West Bank

Gisha's Blog

Recent posts:
Naming the reality‬
12.01.2021
Same storm, different boats‬
23.12.2020
“Holidays are sad days”‬
16.12.2020
Donate
Get information
1.4 Million Did you know that seventy percent of the population in Gaza, 1.4 million people, are under 30 years old?
Watch the video
Gallery
Distant | Relatives
facebook icon   Gisha on Facebook
twitter icon   Gisha on Twitter
  • Homepage
  • About
  • About Gisha
  • Board
  • Gisha Staff
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use
  • Vacancies
  • Legal Activity
  • Legal Advocacy
  • Procedures and Protocols
  • Media
  • Gisha in the media
  • News Releases
  • Reports & Data
  • Publications
  • Graphs
  • Gaza Up Close
  • Gallery
  • Image Gallery
  • Video Gallery
  • Updates
  • Updates
  • Gisha in Action
  • Get Involved
  • Donate
  • Get information
  • Contact Us
 TechnoCraft |  בניית אתרים | סטודיו ג2 | Copyright © 2021 Gisha.org